New Delhi: The Lok Sabha on Monday witnessed a fierce face-off between Opposition chief Rahul Gandhi and the Treasury benches. When he tried to learn out excerpts from former military chief MM Naravane’s unpublished memoirs concerning the 2020 China border disaster, he drew repeated objections from Speaker Om Birla, Protection Minister Rajnath Singh, Dwelling Minister Amit Shah and others.
Mr. Birla’s refusal to permit Mr. Rahul to cite from an unpublished e book sparked an uproar that led to the Home being adjourned a number of occasions and finally discontinuing proceedings.
Rahul tried to learn out the contents of a information article. caravan Journal containing excerpts first printed by. press belief of india In December 2023. It was additionally printed in ThePrint. PTI report on that web site.
The excerpt was concerning the decision-making course of concerning Rechin La. Tensions between India and China and using tank columns. By the way, ThePrint was the primary to report the total particulars of the operation, which was described as a “move seize”.
Simply as Rahul started his speech on the movement of thanks, he was interrupted by the protection minister. above President’s speech. The Congress MP stated he had not supposed to boost the problem in his speech however was pressured to take action after Bharatiya Janata Occasion MP Tejasvi Surya questioned the Congress’ patriotism and understanding of Indian tradition.
“a A younger colleague there made a case in opposition to the Nationwide Congress Occasion. I did not imply to boost this difficulty, however since he raised points about our patriotism and understanding of Indian tradition, I assumed I would learn one thing first. That is from Military Chief Naravane’s memoirs. Pay attention fastidiously, you’ll know precisely who’s patriotic and who shouldn’t be,” Rahul stated.
“This was when 4 Chinese language tanks had been getting into Indian territory. They had been occupying the Doklam ridge, the military chief wrote. Quoting from an article quoting his e book, the tanks had been inside just a few hundred meters of Indian positions within the Kailash vary,” he continued, urging the protection minister to face up and protest.
“Has the e book during which he talked about this stuff been printed? If that’s the case, I’ll point out it. But when it has not been printed, it isn’t applicable to say it,” Singh stated. Rahul claimed the e book was “100 per cent genuine” and that Singh was “rehearsing as a result of his identify shall be talked about”.
Shin countered, saying, “I simply need you to reply whether or not the e book has been printed. If not, it is best to make clear which e book you might be quoting from.” Rahul then held up a replica of the journal during which the excerpt was printed and urged the house minister to intervene.
In October 2025, in response to a query about ready for presidency approval to publish his memoir:“4 Stars of Future”–Naravane stated the writer had submitted the e book to the Ministry of Protection for evaluation.
“So it isn’t for me to comply with up. The ball is within the court docket of the writer and the MoD. However for higher or worse, I had enjoyable penning this e book and that is it. The MoD will give permission once they see match,” he stated.
A December 2023 PTI information report consists of Mr. Naravane’s account of the tense state of affairs that arose after the motion of 4 Chinese language tanks alongside the Line of Precise Management in jap Ladakh on the night time of August 31, 2020.
In his unpublished briefing, Naravane additionally detailed steps taken to cease Chinese language tanks from getting into Indian territory and forestall additional escalation, together with interactions with political leaders.
“You may write about something in {a magazine},” Shah stated, difficult Rahul to show his level. In response, Rahul reiterated that the excerpts had been “assured to be genuine” and added: “Normal Naravane stated the federal government has not approved their publication.”
At this level, Mr. Birla intervened and stated that even when a e book is printed, MPs can not learn out its contents on the ground of the Home.
When Rahul refused to go away the scene, his microphone was lower off.
Defending Rahul, SP chief Akhilesh Yadav stated, “The China drawback could be very critical. If there’s a proposal that’s within the nationwide curiosity, I feel the MPs ought to learn it. Dr Ram Manohar Lohia, Mr George Fernandes and Mr Netaji (Mulayam Singh Yadav) have all the time stated that we should always all the time be cautious of China.”
When the Home reconvened at 4 p.m., Bharatiya Janata Occasion MP Jagdambika Pal took over the function of speaker. Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Dwelling Minister Shah additionally left the Home. The Minister of Protection was current.
“There’s a essential difficulty that I used to be attempting to boost. It’s a nationwide safety difficulty. I do not perceive what’s in these phrases that the Prime Minister and Amit Shah have run away with,” Rahul stated, pointing to the absence of Modi and Shah on the Treasury benches.
Parliamentary Affairs Minister Kiren Rijiju took exception to using the phrase “escape”.
Ultimately, at 4:10 p.m., the Home adjourned for the day.
(Edited by Ajeet Tiwari)
Additionally learn: Military Chief slams China’s infrastructure push in Shaksgam Valley. “That is thought of an unlawful act.”
